Investigación clínica y practica psicoterapéutica: un abismo que salvar


  • Pio Scilligo


Palabras clave:

terapeuta, ajuste emocional, estimulación, práctica en psicoterapia


El artículo revisa de forma crítica los distintos intentos que se han llevado a cabo en el campo de la investigación de la eficacia psicoterapéutica. Los resultados desconcertantes que se derivan de tales estudios llevan a replantear la filosofía de investigación en psicoterapia, poniendo el acento en la dificultad de diseñar modelos capaces de recoger toda la complejidad del proceso psicoterapéutico.


Los datos de descargas todavía no están disponibles.


ANCHIN, J.C., KIESLER, D.J. (eds. 1982), Handbook of interpersonal psychotherapy, New York, Pergamon.

BARLOW, D.H., (1980). Behavior therapy: The next decade, Behavior Therapy, Ml: 315-328.

BABBIE, E. (1973), Survey research methods, Belmont (CA), Wadsworth,

BARLOW, D. (1981), On the relation of clinical research to clinical practice: Current issues, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 49: 147-155.

BARLOW, D.H., HERSEN, M. (1984), Single case experimental designs: strategies for studying behavior change, New York, Pergamon.

BARLOW, D., HAYES, $., NELSON, R. (1984), The scientist-practitioner, New York, Pergamon.

BARRETT, C., HEMPE, E., MILLER, L. (1979), Research on psychotherapy with children, in $. Garfield, A.

Bergin (eds.), Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change, New York, Wiley, 411-435.

BATTACCHI, M. (1988), Appunti sul tema degli obiettivi in psicoterapia, Rivista di Psicologia Clinica, 1: 281- 290.

BECK, T., RUSH, A., SHAW, B., EMERY, G. (1979), Cognitive therapy of depression, New York, Guilford.

BEDELL, J., WARD, J., ARCHER, R., STOKES, M. (1985). An empirical evaluation of a model of knowledge utilization, Evaluation Review, 9: 109-126.

BERGIN, A.E. (1965), Some implications of psychotherapy research for practice, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 71: 235-246.

BERGIN, A.E., LAMBERT, M.J. (1978). The evaluation of therapeutic outcome, in S.L. Garfield, A.E. Bergin (eds) Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change: An empirical analysis (2nd ed.), New York, Wiley, 39-190.

BORDIN, E.S. (1979). The generalizability of the psychoanalytic concept of working alliance, Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 6: 252-260.

CAPLAN, N., MORRISON, A., STAMBAUGH, R. (1975), The use of social science knowledge in policy decisions at the national level, Ann Arbor, University of Michigan, Institute for Social Research, Center for Research on Utilization of Scientific Knowledge.

COHEN, L. (1977), Factors affecting the utilization of mental health evaluation research findings, Professional Psychology, 8: 526-534.

COHEN, L. (1979a), Clinical psychologists' judaments of the scientific merit and clinical relevance of psychotherapy outcome research, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 47: 421-423.

COHEN, L.. (1979b), The research readership and information source reliance of clinical psychologists, Professional Psychology, 10: 780-785.

COHEN, L. (1980), Methodological prereguisites for psychotherapy outcome research, Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Uulization, 2: 263-272.

COHEN, L. SUCHY, K. (1979), The bias in psychotherapy research evaluation, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 35: 181-184. DERNER, G.F. (1965), Graduate education in clinical psychology, in B.B. Wolman (ed.), Handbook of clinical psychology, New York, McGraw Hill.

DUHEM., P. (1962), The aim and structure of physical theory (P.P. Weiner Trans.), New York, Atheneum.

ELLIOTT, R. (1983), Fitting process research to the practicing psychotherapist, Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 20: 47-55.

EMMELKAMP, P.M. (1981), The current and future status of clinical research, Behavioral Assessment, 3: 249- 253.

EYSENCK, H.. (1952), The effects of psychotherapy: An evaluation, Journal of Consulting Psychology, 16: 319-324.

FISKE, D., HUNT, H., LUBORSKY, L., ORNE, M., PARLOFF, M., REISER, M., TUNA, A. (1970), Planning of research on effectiveness of psychotherapy, Archives of General Psychiatry, 22: 22-32.

FRANK. J.D. (1974), Therapeutic components of psychotherapy, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease. 159: 325-342.

FRANK, J.D. (1979), The present status of outcome studies, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 47: 310-316.

FRANK, J.D. (1973), Persuasion and healing: A comparative study of psychotherapy (2nd ed.). Baltimore (MD), Johns Hopkins.

FRANK, J.D., HOEHN-SARIC, R., IMBER, $.D., LIBERMAN, B.L., STRONG, R. (1978). Effective ingredients of successful psychotherapy, New York, Brunner/Mazel.

FREUD, $. (1957[1904]), On Psychotherapy, The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud. London, Hogarth, 255-268.

FREUD, $. (1963af 1917], Analytic therapy, The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud. London, Hogarth, VI: 448-463.

FREUD, $. (1963b[1917]), Transference, The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Siemund Freud, London, Hogarth, XVI: 31-447.

GARFIELD, $.L., BERGIN. A.E. (1978), Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change: An empirical analysis (2nd cd.), New York, Wiley.

GARFIELD, S.L., KURTZ, R. (1976), Personal therapy for the psychotherapist: some findings and issues, Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 13: 188-192.

GENDLIN, E.T. (1986), What comes after traditional psychotherapy research?, American Psychologist, Al: 131-136.

GOEBEL, J.B. (1981), Keeping up with the information explosion in psychotherapy research, The Psychothrapy Bulletin, 15: 21-22.

GREENBERG, L.F., SAFRAN, J.D. (1987), Emoton in psychotherapy: Affect, cognition and the process of change, New York, Guilford.

GREENSON, R. (1967), The technigue and practice of psychoanalysis (vol. 1), New York, International University Press.

HAYES, $.C., NELSON, R.O. (1981), Clinically relevant research: Reguirements, problems, and solutions, Behavioral Assessment, 3: M09-215.

HOROWITZ, L.M., SAMPSON, H., SIEGELMAN, E.Y., WOLFSON, A. & WEISS, J. (1975), On the identification of warded of mental contents, Journal of Abnormal Psychology 84: 545-558.

HOROWITZ, LM., MARMAR, C., KRUPNICK, !., WILNER, N., KALTREIDER, N., WALLERSTEIN, R. (1984), Personality styles and brief psychotherapy, New York, Basic Books.

KAZDIN, A. (1980), Research design in clinical psychology, New York, Harper & Row.

KELLY, E.L., GOLDBERG, L.R., FISKE, D.W., KILKOWSKI, J.M. (1978), Twenty-five years later: A follow-up study of the graduate students in clinical psychology assessed in the VA section research project, American Psychologist, 33: 746-755.

KIESLER, D. (1981)., Empirical clinical psychology: Myth or reality?, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 49: 212-215.

KIELSER, D.J. (1966), Some myths of psychotherapy research and the search for a paradigm, Psychological Bulletin, 65: 110-136.

KIESLER, D.J. (197]), Experimental designs in psychotherapy research, in A.E. Bergin & S.L. Garfield (eds.). Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change: An empirical analysis, New York. Wiley: 36-74.

KIRK, S.A., FISCHER, J. (1976), Do social workers understand research?, Journal of education for Social Work, 12: 63-70.

KIRK, S.A., OSMALOV, M.J., FISCHER, J. (1976), Social workers” involvement in research, Social Work, 21:

KLERMAN, G.L. (1983). The efficacy of psychorherapy as the basis for public policy, American Psycholoeist, 38: 929-934.

KLERMAN, G.L. WEISSMAN, M.M., ROUNSAVILLE. B.J. CHEVRON. E.S. (1984), merpersonal psychotherapy of depression, New York, Basic Books.

KOGAN, L. (1963). The uulization of social work research, Social Casework, AA: 569-574.

LAKATOS, 1. (1970). Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes, in 1. Lakatos. A. Musgrave (cds.). Criticism and the growth of knowledee (pp. 91-196), Cambridge, Cambridge UniverSity Press.

LOMBARDO. G.P., BERTOLA, A. (1988). Verifica in psicologia clinica e psicoanalisi: proposta di un metodo di confronto, Rivista di Psicologia Clinica. V: 105-119.

LOSITO. V. (1989). La formazione in psicoterapia, Polarita, 3: 144-171.

LUBORSKY, L. (1954), A note on Eysenck `s article “The effects of Psychotherapy': An evaluation. British Journal of Psvcholoey. 45: 129-131.

LUBORSKY, L. (1972), Research cannot yet influence clinical practice. In A. Bergin & H. Strupp (eds), Changing fontiers in the science of psyckotherapy (pp. 120-127). Chicago. Aldine.

LUBORSKY, L. (1984) Principles of psychoanalytic psychotherapy: A mantal for supportive-expressive treatment. New York. Basic Books.

LUBORSKY, L., SPENCE, D. (1978). Ouantitative research on Psychoanalytic therapy, in S. Garfield & A. Bergin (eds), Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change: An empirical analysis (2nd ed), New York, Wiley, 31-368.

LUBORSKY. L. SINGER, B. HARTKE, J., CRITS-CRISTOFEF, P.. COHEN, M. (1984), Shifts in depressive state during psychotherapy: Which concepts of depression fit the context of Mr. O`s shifts?, in L. Rice,

L. Greenberg (eds.), Parteras of Change, New York. Guilford, 157-193.

LUBORSKY, L. SINGER. B. (1975), Comparative studies of psychotherapies. Archives of General Psychiatry, 32: 995-1008.

MALAN, D.H. (1973), The outcome problem in psychitherapy research: A historical review. Archives of General Psychiatry, 29: 719-729.

MEEHL, P.E. (1978), Theoretical risks and tabular asterisks: Sir Karl, Sir Ronald. and the slow progress of soft psychology, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 46: 806-834.

MELTZOFF, J. & KORNREICH, M. (1970). Research iu psvchotherapyv, New York, Atherton.

MITCHELL, H.. MUDD, E. (1957), Anxieties associated with the conduct of the research in a clinical setting. American Journal of Orhopsvchiatry, 27: 310-323.

MORROW-BRADELY, C., ELLIOTT. R. (1986), Uiilization of psychotherapy research by practicing psychotherapists, American Psychologist, 41: 188-197.

NORCROSS, 1.C.. WOGAN, M. (1983). American psychotherapists of diverse persuasions: Characteristics, theories, practices and clients, Professional Psychology: Research and Practice. 14: 529-539.

O'DONOHUE, W. (1989), The (Even) Boulder Model: the clinical psychologist as a metaphsysician-scientistpractitioner, American Psychologist, 44, 1460-1468.

ORLINSKY, D. & HOWARD, K. (1978), The realtion of process to outcome in psychotherapy, in $. Garfield, A. Bergin (eds.), Handbook of psvchoherapy and behavior change: An empirical analysis, (2nd ed.), New York, Wiley, 283-330.

PARLOFF, M.B. (1979). Can psychotherapy research guide the policymaker? A little knowledge may be a dangerous thing, American Psychologist, 34: 296-306.

PARLOFF, M.B. (1982), Psychotherapy research evidence and reinbursment decisions: Bambi meets Godzilla, American Journal of Psychiatry, 139: 718-727.

PARLOFF M.B. (1980), psychotherapy and research: An anaclitic depression, Psychiatry, 43: 279-293.

PARLOFF. M.B., WASKOW, LE., WOLFE, B.E. (1978). Research on therapist variables in relation to process and outcome, in $.L. Garfield, A.E. Bergin (eds.), Handbook of Psychotherapy and behavior change: An empirical analysis (2nd ed), New York, Wiley, 233-282.

PAUL, G .L. (1967), Strategy for outcome research, Journal of Consulting Psychology, 31: 109-118.

PAUL, G.L. (1969), Behavior modification research: desing and tactics, in C.M. Franks (ed.), Befavior therapy: Appraisal and status. New York, McGraw-Hill: 29-62.

PAUL, G.L., LENZ. RJ. (1977). Psychosocial treatment of chronic memal patieuts: Milieu versuy sovriallearning programs, Cambridge (MA), Harvard University Press.

PETERSON. D.R. (1985). Twenty years of practitioner training in psychology, American psychologist, 40: 441- 451.

POPPER, K.R. (1961), die open society and its enemies, London, Routledge & Kengan Paul.

PROCHASKA, J.O., NORCROSS, J.C. (1983), Contemporary psychotherapists: A national survey of characteristics, practices, orientations, and attitudes, Psvchitherapy.: Theory, Research and Practice, 20: 161- 73.

RAUSH, H.L. (1974), Research, practice ,and account-ability American Psychologist, 29: 678-681.

RICE. L.N., GREENBERG, L. (eds. 1984), Paterns of change, New York, Guilford.

ROCK, 1. (1983). The logic of perception, Cambridge (MA), The MIT Press.

ROGERS. C.R. (1957), The necessary and sufient condiyions of therapeutic personality change, Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21: 953-103.

RUBINSTEIN. E.A., PARLOFF, M.B. (eds.. 1959), Research in psychorerapy (vol D), Washington DC, American Psychological Association.

SARGENT, M.. COHEN, L.H. (1983), Influence of psychotherapy research on clinical practice: An experimental survey, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. SY: 718-720.

SCHAFFER, N.D. (1982), Multidimensional measures of therapist behavior as predictors of outcome. Psychological Bulletin, 92: 670-681.

SCILLIGO, P. (1988), La ricerca in psicologia: la logica negli esperimenti, Roma, IFREP.

SECBHREST, L. (1975), Research contributions of practicing clinical psychologists, Professional and Psychologv, 6: 41319.

SHAKOW, D. (1976), What is a clinical psychology? American Psychologisi, 3Y: 553-560.

SMITH, M.L.. GLASS, G.V., MILLER, T.1. (1980). The benefits of psyckorherapy, Baltimore (MD), Johns Hopkins University Press.

STRUPP, H.H. (1973). On the basic ingredients of psychotherapy, Journal of Consulting and Clinical

Psychology, 41: 1-8.

STRUPP, H. (1981), Clinical research, practice. and the ensis of confidence, Journal of Cousulting and Clinical Psychology, 49: 216-219.

STRUPP. H.H. (1986), Psychotherpy: Research, Practice and Public Policy (How to avoid dead ends), American Pyychologisis, 41, 120-130.

STRUPP, H.H. & BERGIN, A.E. (1969), Some empirical and concepiual bases for coordinated research in psychotherapy;: A critical review of issues, trends, and evidence, /nernational Journal of Psychiatry, 7: 18-90.

STRUPP. H.H., BINDER. J.L. (1984), Psychorherapv in a new key: A guide to ime-limited dynamic psychorherapy, New York, Basic Books.

STRUPP, H.H.. HADLEY, $.W. (1977), A tripartite model of mental health and therapeutic outcomes: With

Special reference to negative effects in psychotherapy, American Psychologist, 32: 187-196.

STRUPP, H.H., LUBORSKY, L. (Eds., 1962), Research in psychorherapy (vol 2), Washington DC, American Psychological Association.

WARD, C.H. (1964), Psychotherapy research: Dilemmas and directions, Archives of General Psychiatry, 10:596-622.

WEISS, C.H., BUCUVALAS, M.J. (1980), Social science research and decision making, New York, Columbia University Press.

YEATON, W.H., SECHREST, L. (1981). Critical dimensions in the choice of succesful treatments: Strength, integrity and efectiveness, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 49: 156-167.

YOUNG, D.M. & BEIER, E.G. (1982), Being asocial in social places: Giving the client a new experience, in J.C. Anchin, D.J. Kiesler (eds.), Handbook of interpersonal psychorherapy (pp. 262-273), New York, Pergamon Press.



Cómo citar

Scilligo, P. (1990). Investigación clínica y practica psicoterapéutica: un abismo que salvar. Revista De Psicoterapia, 1(4), 9–31.



Artículo de monográfico