Víctimas y victimización colectiva en conflictos de larga duración. El papel de la Historia: el caso de Israel-Palestina
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5944/hdp.38.2021.40319Resumen
La competición de victimización, que suele darse en conflictos de larga duración como el israelí- palestino, forma parte del mismo conflicto y es un obstáculo para su resolución. La historia, y su narración, son elementos clave en el proceso. Siguiendo una periodización entrecruzada, el artículo examina las principales dinámicas que llevan a esa competición y las diversas iniciativas para salir de la espiral victimista, centrándose exclusivamente en las compartidas por palestinos e israelíes. Se hace una exposición sintética de las mismas y de sus resultados, así como de las críticas que suscitan, especialmente las dirigidas contra la ‘normalización’, para terminar en una «in-conclusión» abierta.
Descargas
Citas
ADWAN, S., & BAR-ON, D. (2004). Shared history project: A PRIME example of peace-building under fire. International Journal of Politics,...
ADWAN, S. Dar BAR-ON et al., 2005 [2003]. La Historia Del Otro. Israel y Palestina, Un Conflicto, Dos Miradas. Madrid: Intermon Oxfam
AFSAI, Shai. 2012. «The bride is beautiful, but she ismarried to another man»: Historical Fabricationand an Anti-Zionist Myth», Shofar 30...
AGHA, Hussein & Robert MALLEY. 2001, Camp David: The Tragedy of Errors. The New York Review of Books (48_13), 9/08.
AL-HARDAN, Anaheed. 2015. «Al-Nakbah in Arab Thought. The Transformation of a Concept.»Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and theMiddle...
AMANEY, Jamal, 2007, Barriers to Democracy: The Other Side of Social Capital in Palestine and the Arab World Princeton, NJ: Princeton University...
AMIR, Ruth. 2011. Who is afraid of Historical Redress?The Israeli Victim/Perpetrator Dichotomy Brighton:Academic Studies Press.
ARENDT, Hannah. 1999. Eichmann en Jerusalén. Barcelona:Lumen
AVISHAI, Bernard, 2010.» Against Boycott and Divestment Punishing Israel’s most progressive elementswill not help to end the occupation»....
BACONI, Tareq, 2019. The False Promise of Protest.Foreign Policy, 3 Mayo
BACONI, Tareq, 2018. Hamas contained: the rise and pacification of Palestinian resistance. Stanford: Stanford UniversityPress.
BARGHOUTI, Omar, 2017, «Two Degrees of Separation:Israel, Its Palestinian Victims, and the Fraudulent Use of Antisemitism», en JVFP (ed)On...
BARGHOUTI, Omar, 2011. Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions_ The Global Struggle for Palestinian Rights. London: Haymarket Books.
BARON, Salo W. 1928 «Ghetto and Emancipation: Shall We Revise the Traditional View?» Menorah Journal 14 (1928): 515
BARREÑADA, Isaías (coord.), Álvarez-Ossorio,J.Abu Tarbush, 2018. Entre España y Palestina Revisión crítica de unas relaciones Barcelona: Bellaterra.
BAR-TAL, Daniel., CHERNYAK-HAI, L., SCHORI,N., & GUNDAR, A. 2009. A sense of perceived collective victimhood in intractable conflicts....
BAR-TAL, D, 2007. Sociopsychological foundations of intractable conflicts. American Behavioral Scientist,50, 1430-1453.
BASHIR, Bashir & Amos GOLDBERG, eds. 2019.The Holocaust and the Nakba. A New Grammar of Trauma and History. N. York: Columbia University...
BAUER, Yehuda, 1994. Jews for sale? Negotiations between Jews and Nazis 1933-1945. .Haven: Yale University Press.
BAUER, Yehuda, 2001 Rethinking the Holocaust. N. Haven: Yale University Press.
BEKERMAN, Zvi & Michalinos ZEMBYLAS. 2011.Teaching contested narratives : identity, memory,and reconciliation in peace education and beyond....
BEN-YEHUDA, Omri, 2019, «Ma’abara: Mizraim BetweenShoah and Nakba», en BASHIR, B. & Goldberg,eds. 2019, The Holocaust and the Nakba. A...
BERGMAN, Ronen. 2018. Rise and Kill First. The SecretHistory of Israel’s Targeted Assassinations. N.York:Random House.
BUSBRIDGE, Rachel. 2018. «Israel-Palestine and the Settler Colonial ‘Turn’: From Interpretation to Decolonization.» Theory, Culture &...
BUTLER, Judith. 2012. Parting ways: Jewishness and the critique of Zionism, New directions in critical theory.New York: Columbia University...
BUTLER, Judith, 2006 [2004] Vida Precaria. El poder del duelo. Barcelona.Paidós.
CAPLAN, Neil, 2012, «Victimhood in Israeli and Palestinian National Narratives». Bustan, The Middle East Book Review, 3(2012) 1-19.
CHAZAN, Naomi, 2005. «Peace action and Conflict Resolution An Israeli-Palestinian Exploration,» en Podeh, Elie et al. (eds.), 2005. Arab-Jewish...
CHAZAN, Naomi, 1991, «Israeli Women and Peace Activism», enCalling the Equality Bluff: Women in Israel, edited by B. SWIRSKI and M. P. SAFIR,...
DANIELE, Giulia. 2018. Women, Reconciliation and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. The road not yet taken. N.York: Routledge.
ELDAR, Akiva& Idith ZERTAL. 2007. Lords of theLand: The War for Israel’s Settlements in the Occupied Territories 1967-2007. N. York: Nation...
FINKELSTEIN, Norman G. 2018. Gaza. An Inquest into its Martyrdom: University of California Press.
FISCHBACH, Michael R. 2003. Records of Dispossession:Palestinian Refugee Property and the Arab-IsraeliConflict. N.York: Institute for Palestine...
GILMAN, S.L.1986. Jewish Self-Hatred: Anti-Semitismand the Hidden Language of the Jews. John HophkinsUniv.
GOLANI Motti & Adel MANNA, 2011Two Sidesof the Coin: Independence and Nakba 1948. TwoNarratives of the 1948 War and Its Outcome, Dordrecht:Republic...
GÓMEZ, Luz ed. 2014. BDS por Palestina. Madrid:Disenso. Ed. Oriente y el Mediterráneo
GORNY, Joseph. 2006. Converging Alternatives. TheBund and the Zionist Labor Movement,1897–1985.N. York:
SUNY.HARKABI, Yehoshafat, 1974 [1972] Arab Attitudes toIsrael. N. York. Routledge.
HERZL, Theodor, 1896. Der Judenstaat. (El estado judío; trad. A. Hermosa, B. Aires: Prometeo, 2005)
JVFP. Jewish Voice for Peace, [Foreword by JudithButler], ed. 2017. On Antisemitism. Solidarity andthe Struggle for Justice. Chicago, Illinois:...
KABHA, Mustafa, 2018, «The Life of Jewish Immigrantsfrom Muslim Countries in the Transit Camps as Reflected in the Arabic Journalistic Discourse...
KARMI, Ghada, 2007. Married to Another Man: Israel’s Dilemma in Palestine London: Pluto Press.
KAUFMAN-LACUSTA, Maxine. 2011. Refusing to beenemies: [Palestinian and Israeli nonviolent resistance to the Israeli occupation]. Reading:...
KHALILI, Laleh. 2007. Heroes and Martyrs of Palestine The Politics of National Commemoration. N. York: Cambridge University Press
KHOURY, Elias, 2019, Foreword. En BASHIR, Bashir,and Amos GOLDBERG, eds. 2019. The Holocaustand the Nakba.
KHOURY, Elias, 2018, Les enfants du ghetto. Je m’appelle Adam. Paris. Actes Sud
KIDRON, Peretz, ed. 2004. Refusenik! Israel’s Soldiersof Conscience. Foreword, Susan SONTAG ed.London: Zed Books
LACAPRA, Dominick. 2005 [2001]. Escribir la Historia,Escribir el Trauma. B. Aires. Nueva Visión
LEVI, Primo, 2002 [1989], Los hundidos y los salvados.Barcelona: El Aleph.
LEVI, Primo, 2000 [1958] Si esto es un hombre. Madrid: Muchnick
LINN, Ruth. 1996, Conscience at War. N. York, SUNY Press
LITVAK, Meir & Esther WEBMAN. 2009. From empathy to denial: Arab responses to the Holocaust.London: Hurst.
LÓPEZ ALONSO, Carmen. 2016. «Víctimas en Israel-Palestina». Claves de Razón Práctica 246: 58-69.
LÓPEZ ALONSO, Carmen, 2009 «Historia y presente en Israel y Palestina. Separación, oposición y entrecruzamiento dedos historias paralelas....
LÓPEZ ALONSO, Carmen, 2007, Hamas, la marcha hacia el poder. Madrid,La Catarata.
LÓPEZ ALONSO, Carmen, 2003. «Holocausto y genocidios. ¿Basta con conocer? La acción, la omisión, las interpretaciones históricas.» Historia...
MAIER, Charles S., 2000, «Consigning the Twentieth Century to History: Alternative Narratives forthe Modern Era» American Historical Review...
MANN, Michael, 2012. The sources of social power IV.Globalizations, 1945-2011). New York: Cambridge University Press.
MAOZ, Ifat. 2011. «Does contact work in protracted asymmetrical conflict? Appraising 20 years of reconciliation-aimed encounters between IsraeliJews...
MARGALIT, Avishai, 2018, «Confederation: The One Possible Israel-Palestine Solution». The New York Review of Books (2.02.2018)
MAZOWER, Mark. 2018. What you did not tell. A RussianPast and the Journey Home. N. York: Penguin.
MICHELS, Jefrey, 1994, «National Vision and the Negotiation of Narratives: The Oslo Agreement»,Journal of Palestine Studies 24, n.º 1
MINCZELES, Henri. 1995. Histoire générale du Bundun mouvement révolutionnaire juif. Paris: Austral.
MISHAL, Shaul and Reuben AHARONI. 1994. Speaking Stones: Communique's from the Intifada Underground.Syracuse NY: Syracuse University Press
MORRIS, Benny. 2004. The birth of the Palestinian refugee problem revisited N.York: Cambridge University Press.
NEVE SHALOM-WAHAT AL-SAL: http://nswas.org/NOOR, Massi & al., 2012. «When suffering begetssuffering: The psychology of competitive victimhood...
PAPPE, Ilan. 2017. The Biggest prison on earth. A History of the Occupied Territories. London: One World
PAPPE, Ilan & HILAL, Jamil, «PALISAD Palestinian and Israeli Academics in Dialogue» en Hilal&-Pappe eds.2010. Across the Wall: Narratives...
PELEG, Ilan ed. 2019 Victimhood discourse in Contemporary Israel. N. York: Lexington Books.
PESSIN, Andrew& BEN-ATAR, Doron S. eds. 2018.Anti-Zionism on campus: the university, free speech,and BDS Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana...
PILECKI, Andrew& AMMACK, Phillip L. 2014, «Victims» Versus «Righteous Victims»: The Rhetorical Construction of Social Categories in Historical...
PINSKER, Leo, 1916 [1882] Autoemanzipation. Berlin:Commissions-Verlag.
PITERBERG, Gabriel. 2001. «Erasures.» New Left Review(10): 31.
PODEH, Elie,& ALAYAN, Samira eds. 2018. Multiple Alterities. Views of Others in Textbooks of the MiddleEast. N. York: Palgrave.
PORAT, Dina, 1995, «Attitudes of the Young State of Israel toward the Holocaust and Its Survivors: A Debate over Identity and Values, en L....
RAM, Uri. 2018. Israeli Sociology. Text in Context. N.York: Palgrave.
ROGAN, Eugene & SHLAIM, Avi, eds. 2001. The Warfor Palestine. Rewriting the History of 1948. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ROTBERG, Robert I., ed. 2006. Israeli and Palestinian narratives of conflict: history’s double helix. Bloomington:Indiana University Press.
ROUHANA, Nadim & SABBAGH-KHOURY, Areej2019. «Memory and the Return of History in a Settler-Colonial Context: The Case of the Palestinians...
ROY, Sara 2011. Hamas and Civil Society in Gaza. Engaging the Islamist Social Sector. Princeton, Oxford,N. York: Princeton University Press
SA’DI, Ahmad H. 2008 «Remembering al-Nakba ina Time of Amnesia: On Silence, Dislocation and Time,» Interventions 10, n.1 3(2008): 381–399.
SACHAR, Howard M.1977[1958], The course of Modern Jewish History Dell Publ. N. York
SAID, Edward 1980 [1979] The Question of Palestine.N. York: Vintage.
SAID, Edward, 1979. Zionism from the Standpoint of Its VictimsSocial Text, No. 1. (Winter, 1979), pp. 7-58.
SAID, Edward, 1997. «Bases for Coexistence « Al-Hayat (reproducidoen The End of the Peace Process: Oslo andAfter, New York: Vintage Books,...
SALAMANCA, Omar J. et allii. (2012) Past is Present:Settler Colonialism in Palestine, Settler Colonial Studies, 2:1, 1-8,
SAND, Shlomo 2008. Comment le peuple juif fut inventé.Paris: Fayard.
SASSON-LEVY, Orna, LEVY Yagil & LOMSKY-FEDEREdna 2011, «Women Breaking the Silence:Military Service, Gender, and Antiwar Protest»,Gender...
SAYIGH, Yezid, 1997 (reprint.2004,) Armed Struggleand the Search for State: The Palestinian National Movement, 1948 – 1993. Cambridge: Cambridge...
SAYIGH, Yezid, 1992, «Turning Defeat into Opportunity: The Palestinian Guerrillas After the June 1967 War» TheMiddle East Journal; Spring...
SEGEV, Tom, 1993, The Seventh Million. The Israelisand the Holocaust. Hill and Wang. N.York (originalhebreo Ha-milyon ha-shevii, 1991, Jerusalem).
SEGEV, Tom, 1998 [1984] 1949. The first Israelis, N. York: OwlBooks
SHAFIR, Gershon &PELED, Yoav. 2002. Being Israeli.The Dynamic of Multiple Citizenship. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press.
SHENHAV, Yehouda, 2006 [2004]. The Arab Jews: a post colonial reading of nationalism, religion, and ethnicity(Yehudim-ha-’Arvim) Stanford,...
SHIHADE, Magid (2012) Settler Colonialism and Conflict: The Israeli State and its Palestinian Subjects,Settler Colonial Studies, 2:1, 108-123
SHIMONY, Batya. 2015, «Holocaust Envy: Globalization of the Holocaust in Israeli Discourse» En Goldberg, Amos & Haim Hazan, eds. 2015....
SHLAIM, Avi. 2012. «The Iron Wall Revisited.» Journalof Palestine Studies 41 (2):80.
SHLAIM, Avi, 2014 [2000]. The Iron Wall, Israel and the Arab World. [El muro de hierro. Valencia, Alted. 2003]. N.York: W.W. Norton &...
SHOHAT, Ella. 2017. «The Alphabet of Dispossession» On the Arab-Jew, Palestine, and Other Displacements.Selected Writings. London: Pluto (178-181)
SHOHAT, Ella, 1998 «Sephardim in Israel: Zionism from the Standpoint of its Jewish Victims» Social Text, 37.
SHULMAN, David, 2018, Freedom and Despair: Notes from the South Hebron Hills. Chicago, London:University of Chicago Press.
SHULMAN, David, 2007. Dark Hope. Working for Peace in Israel and Palestine. Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press.
SZNAJDER, Mario. 2007. «Del Estado-refugio al Estado-conflicto: el Holocausto y la formación del imaginario colectivo israelí.» Revista Mexicana...
STERNHELL, Zeev. 2013 [2004.1996]. Los orígenes de Israel. Las raíces profundas de una realidad conflictiva. Trad. Barbara Poey. Buenos Aires:...
STERNHELL, Zeev, 2010,»Socialismo y nacionalismo en Israel.» Claves de Razón Práctica 202: 61-65.
TAMARI, Salim, 2005, «Kissing Cousins: A Note on a Romantic Encounter,» Palestine-Israel Journal12–13, no. 4 (2005): 16-18.
THRALLl, Nathan. 2017. The Only Language They Understand_Forcing Compromise in Israel and Palestine.N. York: Metropolitan Books.
TURNER, Victor W. 1991. The ritual process: structure and anti-structure. 1969 ed. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornel lUniversity Press.
VV.AA., 2012 [2011] [Breaking the Silence]. El libronegro de la ocupación. Testimonios de soldados israelíes en los territorios ocupados....
WEBMAN, Esther, 2017, «Stealing the Holocaust from the Jews»? The Holocaust as Metaphor in Public Discourse, en Mc Elligott,A. & Jeffrey...
WERNER, Michael & Bénédicte ZIMMERMANN.2006. «Beyond comparison: Histoire Croisée andt he challenge of reflexibility», History and Theory45...
YOGEV, Linda, and Gallia LINDENSTRAUSS, eds. 2017. The Delegitimization Phenomenon: Challenges and Responses [Memorandum 169]. Tel Aviv: INSS
YIZHAR, S. 2008. Khirbet Khizeh. 1949 (hebreo) Jerusalem:Ibis editions.
ZERGER NATHAN, Jesse. 2007. Equality Within Difference:The Story of Neve Shalom/Wahat al-Salam.Peace & Change 32 (3):255-300.
ZERTAL, Idith 2005. Israel’s Holocaust and the Politics of Nationhood (Umah veha-mayet), Trans.ChayaGalai. N.York, Cambridge UK: Cambridge...
ZERTAL, Idith, 1998. From Catastrophe to Power. Holocaust Survivorsand the Emergence of Israel. Berkeley, LosAngeles: University of California...
ZERUBAVEL, Yael. 1995. Recovered Roots: collectivememory and the making of Israeli national tradition.Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Descargas
Publicado
Cómo citar
Número
Sección
Licencia
Esta obra está bajo una licencia internacional Creative Commons Atribución-NoComercial 4.0.
