Platonic dialectics and methodology
Abstract
The objective of this work is to apply the analogical dialectic developed by Plato as an adequate methodology to understand his thinking. In this sense, I will first address the terminological clarifications necessary to delimit the approach to the issue and pay special attention to the notion of symploké introduced by Plato and later developed by Jesus G. Maestro as one of the central hermeneutical criteria that the Critique of literature must take into account to avoid falling into the interpretative univocity or the own equivocality of postmodernity. Second, I will make a methodological approach to the reading of the dialogues of Plato in order to show the necessary articulation of the dramatic and doctrinal aspects to understand the Platonic philosophy from the notions of dialectic and analogy. From this perspective, I will present in third place the notion of dialectics in some dialogues of Plato and the use of analogy to show to what extent dialectical methodology can be the instrument capable of guiding reason in the process of ascension towards the search for truth.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDF (Español (España))References
Agamben, G. (2010). Signatura rerum. Barcelona: Anagrama.
Alvarez, L. M. (Noviembre, 2011). El filósofo como theatés y el sofista como mimetés. Platón frente a la sofística y el paradigma del teatro. III Congresi de la Asociación Latinoamericana de Filosofía Antigua. Alfa, Lima.
Alvarez, L. M. (Marzo, 2013). Las relaciones dialéctico-teatrales entre filósofo y sofista formuladas en República, Sofista y Político. XVI Congreso Nacional de Filosofía. Asociación Filosófica Argentina, Buenos Aires, 2013.
Aragües, J. (2002). Preceptiva, sermón barroco y contención oratoria: el lugar del ejemplo histórico. Criticón.
Aullón de Haro, P. (1994). Teoría de la crítica literaria. Madrid: Trotta.
Beuchot, M. (2016). Dialéctica de la analogía: Barcelona: Paidós.
Beuchot, M. (2015). Elementos esenciales de una hermenéutica analógica, 60(74).
Carvallo y Chartier (2001). Historia de la lectura en el mundo occidental. Taurus
De Angelis, L. (2016). Platone e l’antica disputa tra ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑ E ΠΟΙΗΣΙΣ. Milano.
García-López, J. (1974). La analogía en general. Anuario Filosófico, 7, 193-223
García Hoz, V. (1994). Tratado de educación personalizada. Madrid: Rialp.
García Ruíz, M.J. (2019). Educación comparada, teología y postrelativismo. Revista Española de Educación Comparada, 33, pp. 46-61.
Goldschmidt, V. (1947). Le paradigme dans la dialectique platonicienne. Vrin.
González Escudero, S. (20007). El paradigma de El Político de Platón.
González, J. (1995). Dialectic and Dialogue. Plato’s Practice of Philosophical Inquiry, Evanston (Illinois): Northwestern University Press.
González Maestro, J. (2007). Las ascuas del Imperio. Vigo: Academia del Hispanismo.
González Maestro, J. (2009). ¿Qué es literatura?. Vigo: Academia del Hispanismo.
Mansur y Vázquez (ed.) (2018). Educación y persona. Reflexiones críticas sobre el sentido de la educación. México: Tirant humanidades.
Martínez-Almedia, R. (2010). Mito y paradigma en el Político de Platón. (Tesis doctoral). Universidad Autónoma de Madrid.
Másmela, C. (2006). Dialéctica de la imagen. Anthropos
Migliori, M. (2013). Il disordine ordinato. La filosofia dialettica di Platone. Brescia: Editrice Morcelliana.
Migliori, M. (2019). La belleza della complessità. Studi su Platone e dintorni. Brescia: Editrice Morcelliana.
Monserrat, J. (2001). Actualidad de los estudios platónicos, Lección inaugural, Sociedad de Filosofía de la Región de Murcia, 25 de octubre de 2001 en la Biblioteca Regional de Murcia.
Negrete, J. A. (2015). De la Filosofía como Dialéctica y Analogía. Madrid: Ápeiron.
Platón (2010). Sofista. Madrid: Alianza
Platón (2012). Filebo. Buenos Aires: Losada
Platón (2010). Fedro. Istmo
Platón (2000). Política. Madrid: Gredos
Seguró, M. (2015). Sendas de finitud: analogía y diferencia. Barcelona: Herder.
Vallejo Campos, Á. (2018). Adonde nos lleve el logos. Para leer la República de Platón. Madrid: Trotta.
Villalonga, C. (2016). El ejemplo de los oficios en los diálogos de Platón: una vía acceso a su filosofía. (Tesis doctoral). Universitat de les Illes Balears.
Villegas Paredes, G. (2008). Diferencias léxico-semánticas de documentación escrita en las diferentes órdenes religiosas del siglo XVII español. (Tesis doctoral). Universidad Complutense de Madrid.
Sun, Yu-Jung. (2017). Lies in Plato’s Republic.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5944/reec.34.2019.24723
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2019 Revista Española de Educación Comparada

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
![]() | ![]() | |
![]() | ||
Revista Española de Educación Comparada (REEC) Faculty of Education. UNED.
|
ISSN (printed version): 1137-8654 |
Comments on this article
by senlock senlock senlock (2019-07-04)
by situs jasa88hoki (2019-07-15)
by Mrs Rani Odonnell (2019-09-12)
by Idn Poker idn poker Ceme (2019-10-31)
by Buhar Keyf (2019-11-26)
by sewa villa puncak cipanas (2019-12-04)
by games suki (2020-02-05)
by Daisy Keenan (2020-03-02)
by coe mae (2020-03-04)
by go blok (2020-03-21)
by mbah sukro (2020-03-22)
by bos bos (2020-04-13)
by totong z (2020-04-19)
by sao tol (2020-04-22)
by Marylou Lockwood (2020-04-22)
by bos bos (2020-04-23)
by Thurman Spivey (2020-04-24)
by Melisa Usher (2020-04-27)
by Rolland Jarnigan (2020-04-28)
by Tarah Prendiville (2020-04-28)
by Breanna Broussard (2020-05-02)
by suka tu (2020-05-06)
by Ilse Fredricksen (2020-05-06)
by Leopoldo Hilson (2020-05-07)
by Horace Nisbet (2020-05-13)
by bos bos (2020-05-16)
by bos bos (2020-05-22)
by bos bos (2020-05-23)
by Edith Follansbee (2020-05-24)
by bos bos (2020-05-25)
by bos bos (2020-05-29)
by Shani Hauser (2020-05-31)
by Dalton Truman (2020-06-11)
by bos bos (2020-06-13)
by Emmett Steinberger (2020-06-18)
by topeek topeek (2020-06-25)
by Baqq Bocah Ajaib (2020-06-25)
by bebeeek bebeeek (2020-06-25)
by eekbebe eekbebe (2020-06-26)
by Genia Fihelly (2020-06-26)
by jinglu jinglu (2020-06-27)
by bilu bilu (2020-06-28)
by jinglubilu jinglubilu (2020-06-29)
by bilujinglu bilujinglu (2020-07-01)
by puak puak (2020-07-01)
by beautyy beautyy (2020-07-02)
by beautii beautii (2020-07-03)
by siswa siswa (2020-07-04)
by siswi siswi (2020-07-05)
by siswasiswi siswasiswi (2020-07-06)
by Nathaniel Tierney (2020-07-08)
by leaveday leaveday (2020-07-08)
by siswisiswa siswisiswa (2020-07-09)
by siswisiswa siswisiswa (2020-07-10)
by siswasiswaa siswasiswaa (2020-07-11)
by siswasiswaa siswasiswaa (2020-07-11)
by siswasiswaa siswasiswaa (2020-07-12)
by guruguru guruguru (2020-07-28)
by guruguru guruguru (2020-07-29)
by guruguru guruguru (2020-07-30)
by guruguru guruguru (2020-07-30)
by Agen Idn (2020-08-17)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-22)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-23)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-24)
by dewa po (2020-08-25)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-26)
by dewa p (2020-08-28)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-28)
by setan koe (2020-08-28)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-28)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-29)
by setan iki (2020-08-30)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-30)
by setan alas (2020-08-31)
by justdream justdream (2020-08-31)
by Alisson Silva (2020-09-06)
by lemaksiaww lemaksiaww (2020-09-09)
by dinda dina (2020-09-10)
by juna juniar (2020-09-10)
by veli velisia (2020-09-10)
by Juan Runyon (2020-09-18)
by Monica Fortune (2020-09-18)
by Soon Gillison (2020-09-19)
by Holly Cook (2020-09-19)
by Arlie Wiles (2020-09-19)
by mehmet degirmen (2020-09-23)
by Alfredo Shumaker (2020-09-26)
by Rod Reiner (2020-09-27)
by Jens Throssell (2020-09-28)
by Kristie Strangways (2020-09-28)
by Sung Haswell (2020-10-01)
by akash bathash (2020-10-02)
by Jens Throssell (2020-10-03)
by Robby Tyner (2020-10-04)
by bos bos (2020-10-07)
by Bailey Nagle (2020-10-08)
by Lonny Cleary (2020-10-08)
by reportages2 reportages2 (2020-10-09)
by Craig Boatwright (2020-10-09)
by reportages3 reportages3 (2020-10-10)
by Werner Buxton (2020-10-11)
by reportages4 reportages4 (2020-10-11)
by Toni Barry (2020-10-12)
by Lavada Sparrow (2020-10-13)
by Audry Renard (2020-10-14)
by reportages5 reportages5 (2020-10-14)
by reportages6 reportages6 (2020-10-16)
by reportages7 reportages7 (2020-10-17)
by Lorena Land (2020-10-17)
by reportages7 reportages7 (2020-10-18)
by Azucena Jacoby (2020-10-18)
by onlinenet1 onlinenet1 (2020-10-19)
by Lovie Brittain (2020-10-20)
by Lily Culler (2020-10-20)
by Wilson Lionel (2020-10-20)
by onlinenet2 onlinenet2 (2020-10-21)
by Shella Hart (2020-10-21)
by Duane Holley (2020-10-21)
by onlinenet3 onlinenet3 (2020-10-22)
by fiona basil (2020-10-23)
by fiona basil (2020-10-23)
by onlinenet4 onlinenet4 (2020-10-23)
by onlinenet5 onlinenet5 (2020-10-24)
by Mallory Clemons (2020-10-24)
by sherly sylvia (2020-10-26)
by fiona basil (2020-10-26)
by onlinenet6 onlinenet6 (2020-10-28)
by fiona basil (2020-10-28)
by Michal Brownlee (2020-10-28)
by sherly sylvia (2020-10-28)
by sherly sylvia (2020-10-29)
by onlinenet7 onlinenet7 (2020-10-29)
by jaka bimo (2020-10-29)
by onlinenet7 onlinenet7 (2020-10-30)
by sherly sylvia (2020-10-31)
by sherly sylvia (2020-10-31)
by fiona basil (2020-10-31)
by fiona basil (2020-10-31)
by onlinenet8 onlinenet8 (2020-10-31)
by andi permana (2020-10-31)
by Casie Rolfe (2020-11-01)
by Polly Kimball (2020-11-02)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-02)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-02)
by fiona basil (2020-11-03)
by fiona basil (2020-11-03)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-03)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-03)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-03)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-03)
by Marcelino Hawthorne (2020-11-03)
by Irish Stiles (2020-11-03)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-04)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-04)
by fiona basil (2020-11-04)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-05)
by fiona basil (2020-11-05)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-05)
by takdir poker (2020-11-06)
by takdir poker (2020-11-06)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-06)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-06)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-06)
by fiona basil (2020-11-06)
by fiona basil (2020-11-06)
by ari handoko (2020-11-06)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-07)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-07)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-07)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-07)
by fiona basil (2020-11-07)
by fiona basil (2020-11-07)
by Joesph Faithfull (2020-11-08)
by Dino Hofmann (2020-11-08)
by Dante Gagai (2020-11-08)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-09)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-09)
by fiona basil (2020-11-09)
by Mirta Roten (2020-11-09)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-10)
by takdir poker (2020-11-10)
by takdir poker (2020-11-10)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-10)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-10)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-10)
by fiona basil (2020-11-10)
by fiona basil (2020-11-10)
by Dieter Lujan (2020-11-10)
by Alisha Lay (2020-11-10)
by Fran McCrea (2020-11-11)
by takdir poker (2020-11-11)
by takdir poker (2020-11-11)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-11)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-11)
by Sam Wan (2020-11-11)
by fiona basil (2020-11-11)
by fiona basil (2020-11-11)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-12)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-12)
by fiona basil (2020-11-12)
by Dominga Smallwood (2020-11-12)
by Lily Lyell (2020-11-12)
by Dane Tye (2020-11-12)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-13)
by takdir poker (2020-11-13)
by takdir poker (2020-11-13)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-13)
by fiona basil (2020-11-13)
by Verena Roe (2020-11-13)
by Katlyn Kwong (2020-11-13)
by Maurine Kwong (2020-11-13)
by Aiden Sticht (2020-11-14)
by Mallory Dundas (2020-11-14)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-16)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-16)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-16)
by fiona basil (2020-11-16)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-16)
by fiona basil (2020-11-16)
by fiona basil (2020-11-17)
by fiona basil (2020-11-17)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-17)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-17)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-17)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-17)
by fiona basil (2020-11-18)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-18)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-18)
by Dian Culler (2020-11-19)
by fiona basil (2020-11-19)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-19)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-19)
by Renee Fortney (2020-11-19)
by Kandi Herrick (2020-11-19)
by fiona basil (2020-11-20)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-20)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-20)
by takdir poker (2020-11-20)
by takdir poker (2020-11-20)
by Sammie Noe (2020-11-20)
by fiona basil (2020-11-21)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-21)
by sherly sylvia (2020-11-21)
by Noe Madison (2020-11-21)
by Martha Lumholtz (2020-11-21)
by Dian Coningham (2020-11-22)
by fiona basil (2020-11-23)
by fiona basil (2020-11-23)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-23)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-23)
by Tonya Rylah (2020-11-23)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-24)
by fiona basil (2020-11-24)
by Gabriella Wallace (2020-11-25)
by Ralf Bigham (2020-11-27)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-27)
by Karolyn Embry (2020-11-27)
by Chantal Cochrane (2020-11-27)
by fiona basil (2020-11-28)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-28)
by fiona basil (2020-11-28)
by fiona basil (2020-11-28)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-28)
by Adrianne Shively (2020-11-29)
by Clint Wroe (2020-11-29)
by Maira Braswell (2020-11-29)
by ancy mathias (2020-11-30)
by fiona basil (2020-11-30)
by Keeley Rincon (2020-12-03)
by Amie Feierabend (2020-12-03)
by Lavon Buckland (2020-12-04)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-04)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-04)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-05)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-05)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-07)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-07)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-08)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-08)
by King Pilcher (2020-12-09)
by Kina Lepage (2020-12-09)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-10)
by Eloisa Keane (2020-12-10)
by takdir poker (2020-12-11)
by takdir poker (2020-12-11)
by takdir poker (2020-12-11)
by takdir poker (2020-12-11)
by Hunter Riggs (2020-12-11)
by judi onlinez (2020-12-11)
by Chasity Kilburn (2020-12-13)
by Marty Bickersteth (2020-12-13)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-14)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-14)
by Dante Sadler (2020-12-14)
by Darcy Belisario (2020-12-14)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-15)
by Hope Corby (2020-12-15)
by fiona basil (2020-12-16)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-16)
by Dawna Villegas (2020-12-16)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-17)
by fiona basil (2020-12-17)
by Maura Gardner (2020-12-17)
by Celeste Gair (2020-12-17)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-18)
by fiona basil (2020-12-18)
by Thanh Colvin (2020-12-18)
by Lazaro Gibb (2020-12-19)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-19)
by takdir poker (2020-12-19)
by takdir poker (2020-12-19)
by fiona basil (2020-12-19)
by romansa demo alat bantu (2020-12-19)
by games winter (2020-12-20)
by Moises Lester (2020-12-20)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-21)
by fiona basil (2020-12-21)
by Juliann Yali (2020-12-21)
by Samira Holt (2020-12-21)
by Jason Strack (2020-12-21)
by Wilma Colley (2020-12-21)
by fiona basil (2020-12-22)
by fiona basil (2020-12-22)
by Mammie Yeo (2020-12-22)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-23)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-23)
by fiona basil (2020-12-23)
by fiona basil (2020-12-23)
by Carin Carnahan (2020-12-23)
by Eunice Payton (2020-12-25)
by Antje Hartung (2020-12-25)
by Jestine Meza (2020-12-25)
by takdir poker (2020-12-26)
by takdir poker (2020-12-26)
by takdir poker (2020-12-26)
by takdir poker (2020-12-26)
by Wilma Colley (2020-12-26)
by Wilma Colley (2020-12-27)
by Wilma Colley (2020-12-28)
by Damian Barajas (2020-12-29)
by Merrill Corones (2020-12-29)
by Dani Ragan (2020-12-29)
by takdir poker (2020-12-30)
by Dacia Giltner (2020-12-30)
by takdir poker (2020-12-30)
by takdir poker (2020-12-30)
by Gabriella Wallace (2020-12-30)
by jusefiz carmelitions (2020-12-30)
by jusefiz carmelitions (2020-12-30)
by Britt Catt (2020-12-31)
by takdir poker (2020-12-31)
by fiona basil (2020-12-31)
by fiona basil (2020-12-31)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-31)
by ancy mathias (2020-12-31)
by Melinda Du Cane (2020-12-31)
by takdir poker (2021-01-01)
by takdir poker (2021-01-01)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-01)
by Bernie Ash (2021-01-01)
by fiona basil (2021-01-02)
by fiona basil (2021-01-02)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-02)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-02)
by takdir poker (2021-01-02)
by Lynn Duquette (2021-01-02)
by Jimmy Foti (2021-01-03)
by Dacia Giltner (2021-01-03)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-03)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-03)
by Chana Metzger (2021-01-03)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-04)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-04)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-04)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-05)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-05)
by fiona basil (2021-01-05)
by takdir poker (2021-01-05)
by takdir poker (2021-01-05)
by Wilma Colley (2021-01-05)
by Jurgen Northfield (2021-01-06)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-07)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-07)
by fiona basil (2021-01-07)
by fiona basil (2021-01-07)
by Renee Cogburn (2021-01-07)
by Katrice Grace (2021-01-08)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-09)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-09)
by Kassie Wile (2021-01-09)
by Clyde Zuniga (2021-01-10)
by Ferne Rumpf (2021-01-10)
by Jenna Greenlee (2021-01-10)
by Estelle Keogh (2021-01-11)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-11)
by fiona basil (2021-01-11)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-11)
by fiona basil (2021-01-11)
by Marcia O'Toole (2021-01-11)
by Dick Bennelong (2021-01-12)
by fiona basil (2021-01-12)
by fiona basil (2021-01-12)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-12)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-12)
by NataliaRocon.com What is the worst case after consuming diet pills? (2021-01-12)
by Lida Garran (2021-01-12)
by Tonia Coneybeer (2021-01-13)
by fiona basil (2021-01-13)
by fiona basil (2021-01-13)
by fiona basil (2021-01-13)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-13)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-13)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-13)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-14)
by Thanh Colvin (2021-01-15)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-15)
by Ardis Wegener (2021-01-16)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-16)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-16)
by fiona basil (2021-01-16)
by fiona basil (2021-01-16)
by sekte lotep (2021-01-16)
by duit u (2021-01-16)
by Trista Silverman (2021-01-16)
by Elise Hawdon (2021-01-16)
by uang n (2021-01-17)
by takdir poker (2021-01-17)
by way ang (2021-01-17)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-18)
by fiona basil (2021-01-18)
by memek a (2021-01-18)
by gol ek (2021-01-20)
by gam bar (2021-01-20)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-20)
by Gabriella Wallace (2021-01-20)
by Isabel Nepean (2021-01-20)
by Nancy Nale (2021-01-21)
by Marlys Genders (2021-01-21)
by to gay (2021-01-23)
by Shayla Bowes (2021-01-23)
by Gabriella Theriault (2021-01-23)
by Kasey Hardesty (2021-01-23)
by Keenan Fleischer (2021-01-24)
by Maritza Ditter (2021-01-24)
by tog ai (2021-01-24)
by Selena Lessard (2021-01-24)
by Odessa Greeves (2021-01-24)
by Dante Tjalkabota (2021-01-24)
by Woodrow Pleasant (2021-01-24)
by Jayne Forney (2021-01-24)
by Alba Withrow (2021-01-24)
by ancy mathias (2021-01-25)
by fiona basil (2021-01-25)
by Taren Flinders (2021-01-25)