What is the place of religious schools in pluralistic democratic societies? A liberal approach to the problematic of religious schools and democratic citizenship in Western societies. The Spanish case

Ignasi Grau Callizo

Abstract


The following article aims to determine under which circumstances the establishment of denominational schools must be allowed in democratic societies. The possible opening of a Muslim Brotherhood School in Spain requires a new approach on the presence of religious schools through the study of the collision between two protected goods raise: freedom of religion and democratic citizenship. Thus, it is first considered which space democratic States must grant to religious institu-tions, turning to Cécile Laborde’s considerations on French laicism from a liberal Span-ish perspective.  Subsequently, the article proceeds to reconcile freedom of religion and democratic citizenship education, choosing the political liberal approach over the com-prehensive liberal approach, since it provides solutions that are easier to assume by the standard reasonable citizen. Once the theoretical framework has been established, the tension between these two goods is analyzed through the triangle of actors of Arneson and Saphiro, in order to determine under what circumstances the existence of denomina-tional schools must be tolerated. Said triangle shows the tension between the State, who seeks to educate good citizens (democratic citizenship education), the parents, who seek that their children share their same conception of the good life (freedom of religion) and, in between, the children, whose best interest must come first. On the one hand, the results do not only show that religious institutions are compatible with democratic States, but also that said States must guarantee, in pluralistic societies, the different conceptions of the good life. On the other hand, regarding the conciliation between freedom of religion and democratic citizenship, the article showcases that, in order for the best interest of the child to be guaranteed, neither the State nor the parents can prevail, rather both interests must balance in the following way: the State must allow the existence of confessional schools as long as they teach the core contents of demo-cratic citizenship education. Finally, the article argues that democratic citizenship education in confessional schools is not inferior to that of public schools, and criticizes the positions according to which citi-zens must put aside the religious aspect in democratic societies. The article pretends to discuss the traditional liberal theoretical framework, from which it has reflected the reli-gious education, compelling a re-reading of the triangle of actors. 


Keywords


Cultural pluralism; religious education, democracy; denominational school; right to education

Full Text:

PDF

References


Arneson, R. J. & Shapiro I., (1996) Democratic Autonomy and Religious Freedom: A critique of Wisconsin v. Yoder. Nomos, 38, Political Order.

Audard, C (2009) Qu’est-ce que le libéralisme ? – Étique, politique, société. Editions Gallimard.

Avins, J. (30 March 2015) Sikhs in the UK have won their right to wear turbans at work. Quartz. Retrieved from https://qz.com/372692/sikhs-in-the-uk-have-won-the-right-to-wear-their-turbans-to-work/

Berglund, J. (2015) Publicly funded Islamic Education in Europe and the United States. The Brookings Project on U.S. Relations with the Islamic World Analysis Paper.

Berlin I, (1999) Mi andadura intelectual. P. Badillo O’Farrell and E. Bocardo, Madrid, Tecnos.

Centro de Investigaciones Sociales (2016) Barómetro de enero 2016. Estudio nº 3124. Retrieved from http://datos.cis.es/pdf/Es3124mar_A.pdf

Conventiones Inter Apostolicam Sedem Et Nationem Hispanam, signed on 1979, ratified the same year. Retrieved from https://www.boe.es/diario_boe/txt.php?id=BOE-A-1979-29491

Corral, C. (2004) Laicidad, aconfesionalidad, separación ¿Son lo mismo? UNISCI Discussion Papers.

European Committee for Catholic Education (2014) School Statistics 2013-2014 Retrieved from http://enseignement.catholique.be/ceec_wp/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Statistiques-scolaires-2014-School-Statistics.pdf

Folgerø and Others V. Norway. Application no. 15472/02, par. 50, ECHR 2007.

Fernandez, A (2009) Le droit à l’éducation: Le droit à être humain. Vers une culture de droits de l’homme. Droits humains, culturels, économie et éducation. Diversités, Genève, pp. 367 -394.

Gosepath, S. (2007) Equality In: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (online) (Accessed 21/04/2017). Retrieved from http://www.citethisforme.com/guides/harvard/how-to-cite-a-dictionary-entry

Gutmann, A. (1980) Children, Paternalism and Education: A Liberal Argument. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 9(4).

Gutmann, A. (1988) Democratic Education. Michigan Law Review, 86(6).

Habermas, J. (2003) De la tolerancia religiosa a los derechos culturales. Claves de la razón práctica.

Habermas j. (2006) Religion in the Public Sphere. European Journal of Philosophy Vol. 14(1), pp. 1–25.

Kant, E. (1910) Traité de pédagogie. Paris.

Laborde, C. (2017) Républicanisme critique et réligion. Movements 2017/1 (nº 89), pp.62-68.

Laborde, C. (2016) Conclusion: Is Religion Special? Religion, Secularism, and Constitutional Democracy, Columbia University Press.

Ley 25/1992, de 10 de noviembre, por la que se aprueba el Acuerdo de Cooperación del Estado con la Federación de Comunidades Israelitas de España. Retrieved from https://www.boe.es/diario_boe/txt.php?id=BOE-A-1992-24854

Ley 24/1992, de 10 de noviembre, por la que se aprueba el Acuerdo de Cooperación del Estado con la Federación de Entidades Religiosas Evangélicas de España Estado con la Federación de Entidades Religiosas Evangélicas de España. Retrieved from https://www.boe.es/buscar/doc.php?id=BOE-A-1992-24853

Ley 26/1992, de 10 de noviembre, por la que se aprueba el Acuerdo de Cooperación del Estado con la Comisión Islámica de España. Retrieved from https://www.boe.es/diario_boe/txt.php?id=BOE-A-1992-24855

Macedo, S. (1995) Liberal Civic Education and Religious Fundamentalism: The Case of God vs. John Rawls? Ethics, 105(3)

Modood, P. (2009) Odd ways of being secular. Social Research, 76(4), The Religious-Secular Divide: The U.S. Case (Winter 2009), pp. 1169 – 1172.

Mounier, E. (1946) Traité du caractère. Divers – Essais.

OIDEL (2016) Freedom of Education Index 2016. Geneva.

Orrico, J. (2005) La ruina de la enseñanza española. Cuadernos de pensamiento político n°8, pp. 24-55.

Palomino, R. (2016) Manual Breve de Derecho Eclesiástico del Estado. 4ª Edición, Madrid.

Partido Popular (2015) El PP subraya su defensa de la libertad de enseñanza y reclama debates serios y rigurosos sobre la educación en España. Retrieved from http://www.pp.es/actualidad-noticia/pp-subraya-su-defensa-libertad-ensenanza-reclama-debates-serios-rigurosos-sobre

Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 (1925)

PSOE (2010) 25 años de la LODE. Retrived from: http://web.psoe.es/educacion/docs/530246/page/anos-la-lode.html

Rawls, J. (1971) A Theory of Justice. Cambridge.

Rawls, J. (1993) Political Liberalism. Columbia University Press.

Serif vs. Greece Application no. 38178/97, par. 53, ECHR 2000.

Smith, S. D. (1996) The unprincipled approach to religious freedom. Capital University Law Review nº 805.

Stuart Mill, J. (1859) On Liberty (Spanish Translation: Sobre la libertad) Alianza Editorial.

Todd, T. (2015) Qui est Charlie? Sociologie d’une crise religieuse. Éditions du Seuil.

Unidos Podemos (2016) Programa Electoral (nº 293). Retrieved from https://lasonrisadeunpais.es/programa/

Verdú, D. (23 enero 2015) El Círculo Islámico de Podemos. El País. Retrieved from http://politica.elpais.com/politica/2015/01/22/actualidad/1421956567_088774.html

Wisconsin v. Yoder 406 U.S. 205 (1972).

World Bank (2014) Percentage of enrolment in primary education in private institutions ( %). World Bank Databank. Retrieved from http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SE.PRM.PRIV.ZS

Zafra, I. (20 Septembre 2016) Una entidad recauda 2,5 millones para abrir un colegio islámico en Valencia. El País. Retrieved from http://ccaa.elpais.com/ccaa/2016/09/20/valencia/1474382064_310654.html




DOI: https://doi.org/10.5944/reec.32.2018.21339

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Copyright (c) 2018 Revista Española de Educación Comparada

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

  

Revista Española de Educación Comparada (REEC)

Faculty of Education. UNED. 
c/ Juan del Rosal, 14
28040 - MADRID (Spain) 
Phone number: +34 654 73 1122
E-mail: reec@edu.uned.es

 

 



ISSN (printed version): 1137-8654
ISSN (electronic version): 2174-5382
Legal Deposit: M.38499-1995